Melissa Gilbert landed the role of Laura Ingalls on Little House on the Prairie in 1974. When her little brother, Jonathan, tagged along for her audition, he was given the part of Walnut Grove troublemaker Willie Oleson. Though his co-star and onscreen sibling Alison Arngrim (Nellie Oleson) adored the young actor, she revealed he had a habit that didn’t sit well with other cast members.
Jonathan Gilbert pretended he couldn’t read
Arngrim shared many scenes with Jonathan since they portrayed brother and sister on Little House. Coming from Walnut Grove’s richest family, Nellie and Willie were known as spoiled bullies that were usually up to no good. Though Arngrim raved of Jonathan in real life, she admitted he liked to pull some antics on set.
“He did come up with things to do just to drive people crazy,” Arngrim wrote in her memoir Confessions of a Prairie B****. “I particularly enjoyed his insistence in the show’s later years that he couldn’t read. He could, obviously, but he found it far more to his advantage to tell people he couldn’t.”
Jonathan was only six years old when he was recruited for the role of Willie, so he could easily get away with not reading scripts. As time went on, he didn’t feel a need to pick up the pace.
“When he first started the show, he actually didn’t read much, so his mother would read his lines to him, and he would learn them that way,” Arngrim explained. “But as he got older, he continued to learn his lines, only without reading the rest of the script. If he wasn’t sure what was happening, he’d just ask someone.”
‘Little House’ star frustrated his teacher
The Little House cast included several child actors, so an on-set teacher provided daily academics. Arngrim gave an example of how Jonathan’s facade grated on his educator.
“I remember him driving our normally calm set teacher, Helen Minniear, practically to drink with this act when we first started the show,” Arngrim noted. “She was going over his reading workbook with him. The word in the sentence was fez, as in the hat. There was a picture of a man wearing what was unmistakably a red, tassled fez. Jonathan dutifully read, ‘The man in the picture is wearing a fuzz’.”
Though Ms. Minniear would repeatedly sound out the short “e” pronunciation, Jonathan would resort back to his charade.
“‘Oh yeah, fez,’ he’d reply, smiling,” Arngrim recalled. “Two seconds later: ‘The man in the picture is wearing a fuzz.'”
